Wednesday, July 8th, 2009

Why Do Men Cheat?

Because they can.

How’s that?

It seems that some of you have been wondering why I haven’t commented on the one story that in my neck of the woods managed to supplant the death of Michael Jackson  this past weekend. And that’s the murder of retired NFL star Steve McNair, married, father of four, by his 20 year old mistress

It’s not because I haven’t kept up with the story that I’ve haven’t brought it up on the blog. Hey, I’m a married woman. Stories of cheating husbands make you sit up and pay attention whether you want to or not. But if you’re one of the two readers who’ve wondered, the answer is simple. I’m not an ambulance chaser. If I chased down every story with tawdry details about yet another married man caught having an affair I wouldn’t be able to blog about anything else. Besides, this isn’t a gossip blog. A blogger who tries to stick with religious and moral dilemmas (mostly) has only so much moral capital to throw around. And I try to expend my limited share where it’s needed the most. Adultery speaks for itself.

But since the other blogpiece I’ve been working on isn’t coming together, and since our appetite for the salicious is still whet after a week of feasting on Michael Jackson’s remains, why not offer a comment or two on what there is to learn from McNair’s tragic end?

Permit me a disclaimer. Like the prophet Paul I write not as a prophet nor as a minister in this blogpost. Not even as a woman of faith necessarily. I write here as a thinking woman who happens to be married.

For those like me who don’t follow football, McNair retired famed NFL player was found murdered in his Nashville condo this past weekend, two shots to the head and two in the chest. His 20 year old girlfriend was sprawled out dead at his feet, one shot to the head, the gun underneath her body on the floor. Officials have all but ruled the deaths a murder-suicide.

McNair retired a year ago from professional football after 13 seasons in the NFL. He was a three times Bowl pick (whatever that means). He played nine seasons as quarterback for the Tennessean Titans before being traded in 2006 to the the Ravens in Baltimore where he retired in 2008. McNair was found dead this past weekend in his Nashville condo,  Black sports fans were especially proud of the fact that McNair, a graduate of Alcorn State, was one of only three quarterbacks in NFL history who was drafted in the first round out of historically black colleges and universities. Friends remember him as a kind and generous sort of fellow. (But as we see with MJ’s death these things get redacted a lot in death.) It’s just a shame that the man died because he couldn’t keep it in his pants. It’s a shame that in addition to his accomplishments on the field he will be remembered off the field as a man who was killed by his mistress who was a high school drop-out.

Did I mention that McNair’s wife of 12 years, Mechelle, mother of the four sons he leaves behind, had no idea about her husband’s affair?
But then the wife is always the last to know. Or, so they say. Another one of those posthumous redactions, I suppose.

definitionof adultery

To the question. Why do men cheat?

Because it’s easy to do. Because it’s one of the privileges that come with patriarchy. Because men claim to need more sex than their wives are willing to put out. (As one man put it, “Men are always thinking about sex: they’re either thinking about the last time they had sex, or thinking about the next they’re gonna have sex.”) Translated: Men cheat because they can’t help themselves. Men cheat because there are women out there who don’t think twice about sleeping with married men. Men cheat because they crave the affirmation and the boost to their ego. Men cheat because of the adrenaline rush they get from sneaking around and getting away with something they’re not supposed to do. Take your pick.

Lots of men do not cheat on their wives (or significant others). Many, many, many do, or so it seems. Especially men who are public figures.

That is, butchers, bakers, and candlestick makers. And lots of politicians too. South Carolina Gov. Mark Sanford, Sen. John Ensign, R-Nev., Sen. David Vitter, R-La., former House Speaker Newt Gingrich, R-Ga., one-time Democratic presidential hopefuls John Edwards and Gary Hart, former New York Gov. Eliot Spitzer, ex-Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick, ex-New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani, ex-DC Mayor Marion Barry, current New York Gov. David Paterson, former President Bill Clinton.

And, oh yeah, there are the preachers.

You’re probably asking, “Do married women cheat?” Of course they do. But that’s not the question on the table.

If I were writing as a minister (which I’m not, mind you) I would probably quote Scripture to bring men to their senses. But the Bible, at least the part written by men, doesn’t say  that adultery is a sin. Not when it’s men doing it. Let me be more specific. Not when it’s a married man having an affair with an unmarried woman. It’s only an affair when he’s having an affair with another man’s wife. As for what the Bible has to say about when a married woman has an affair. Stone her . Whether her lover is married or not. Stone her to death.

Lots of men cheat and never end up having to pay publicly. In times past there were politicians, presidents even, who tipped out and didn’t pay publicly, John F. Kennedy and Franklin D. Roosevelt are two that come to mind.

It’s a different world now. Ours is a public that goes into a feeding frenzy at the opportunity to download stories of marital affairs, review videos of extramarital trysts,  listen in to tape conversations, read text messages and email between clandestine loves, click to examine a mistress’s dress with his DNA still on it. Technology has developed in the public an insatiable appetite for scandal, an appetite that media is only too eager to feed.

Which makes it all the more unfathomable why men, especially men who are famous, tempt fate by cheating on their wives. But they do. Despite living in a fish bowl men like Governor Sanford of South Carolina, you would think, would resist flying the coup and running off to Argentina to see his mistress. But he didn’t.

You would certainly think that adulterers would know that there is no such thing as free extra meal. Eventually the bill comes due. Somebody will pay for those text messages and  hotel bills. And I promise you, it won’t be just you – and your mistress. It will be your family. Especially your wife whose every tear or stoic expression and dress size will end up being parsed by a public that’s dying to know how much she knew, when she knew, what’s wrong with her that she couldn’t keep her man at home, and why does she stay(a topic I’ve addressed before). And then there’s the children, the poor children. The greatest victims of it all. How will the way their father died impact the lives of Steve McNair’s sons as they grow up? Heaven help them.

Moreover, you would think that the fear of disease, public humiliation, losing your job ruining your family life, hurting your wife, damaging your children, and undermining your life’s work would be a deterrent to men who cheat. Not.

So, why do men cheat? Because it’s worth the risk. Or so says the part of the brain that’s responsible for the blood rushing to the penis.

What’s a wife to do? Get a life. Have a plan. And stay on speaking terms with God.

But remember, I’m blogging not as prophet here today, but as a thinking woman who happens to be married.

26 comments so far

So funny to see your first sentence. I had just said the same thing on Facebook a little over a week ago.

ok–so they do because they can. and because it is expected(by other men) accepted ( by “the other woman”) and tolerated/celebrated/excused (by society)

So what does it take to change those expectations (peer pressure-man to man) and be clear about what is not acceptable (co-conspirator women–since they ain’t cheating alone)?

Society does not put up with other individuals who violate trust–child… molesters, doctors who practice euthanasia, or corporations who break contracts for example. Men will cheat as long as we as a society(all of us, both men and women together) tolerate, celebrate, and excuse adultery.

When are we going to raise the standards and hold everyone accountable for making a relationship work?

I know–changing the entire patriarcal system in which we live.
:)

Gotta start somewhere.

It is ok to set (higher) standards and move towards change. Infidelity does not have to be “the norm”.

I have hope that both men and women have the capacity to be self actualized, responsible, responsive, mature individuals enjoying committed, respectful, fulfilling relationships.

I have hope, despite what is in the news
I have hope, despite having been(although unknowingly) for a short while
the “other woman”
I have hope, despite being single.
I have hope and self respect.

T
July 8th, 2009 at 11:24 am

LoL! I get it. This is a subject of much discussion that cut the line between the sexes unevenly. Even men think it is wrong, will not speak out boldly and consistently against the practice. The church ain’t a sista’s friend either. In ancient biblical times, men could go to the priest to remedy her cheating ways, but where does a woman get restitution for her wondering man? There is nothing a woman can do to keep her man faithful. Either he wants to or will not honor his promise. With all the scandals associated with men cheating and ruining their lives, you would think they would deem the price to high to pay. Instead, they run to the fire at record numbers and act like the outcome will be different for them. God Bless the carcasses left behind to deal with the memory of his final days…

Renee
July 8th, 2009 at 2:15 pm

@Monique
Thanks for leaving a comment. But if you don’t mind I’d rather not link to the FoxNews sportswriter whose column on McNair you suggest we all read. His sexist, degrading comments last week about Serena Williams’ butt at Wimbledon make it obvious that he says and does whatever obnoxious thing he must to get readers over to his column.

Renita
July 8th, 2009 at 3:43 pm

I understand. Wasn’t aware. I’ve never read anything prior to this article I received, but to paraphrase, he said it’s hard to hear about someone’s devotion to community service in Tennessee and Mississippi when community service starts at home with your family. He went on to stress that regardless of the unknown condition of his marriage, while he was running around the country with this woman, his four boys needed their father and you can’t serve two households.

It’s unfortunate that “mess” often messes up the “message”. Not the first time, not the last.

Monique
July 8th, 2009 at 5:36 pm

I am suprised that Sanford’s wife is willing to stay with him after he said his mistress was his soul mate. Why would she want to stay with him when he says he’ll try to fall back in love with her?
Today the pastor of the McNair family was on the Early Morning Show. He just wanted to focus on the positive things that McNair did. He needs to be addressing the adultery issue head on.

TMW
July 9th, 2009 at 4:23 am

Thank you Rev. Weems; as always, good point(s).

I wish men who are fathers could simply explain to other men that a really good father honors the mother of his children. Cheating on the wife, the mother of his children, does not honor her or his children.

I can’t imagine the pain, the anguish of being a mother of four children and having to explain to them how and why their father died . . . so needlessly . . . . I wish men (and their mistresses) would stop and think what such actions do to the children . . . . :(

RevMamaAfrika
July 9th, 2009 at 5:09 am

CORRECTED ENTRY

Men cheat because not one of the fantasies they chase is that of their body outlined in white chalk, penetrated with four bullets, from a pistol lying under the body of “the other woman” sharing a like bullet in the brain.

Men cheat because the brain that directs them does not have eyes to see.

Byrda
July 9th, 2009 at 6:50 am

Dr. Weems,
I don’t have any smart, intellectual-sounding response to this one. On this topic, I take a heteronormative stance (I dont’ know why gay men cheat on each other, or why lesbians do so) and only my gut speaks. Men cheat because (we) women are of little value to most of them outside the sexual pleasure and status they may derive from us.
@Byrda,
My sentiments exactly! Men cheat because they don’t care to see what it will cost them (not to mention what it will cost us because that’s never taken into account anyway).

socgrad
July 9th, 2009 at 8:34 am

i’m not married so i’ll keep my comment brief. when i first heard about his murder, all i could think of was otis redding.

afrodite
July 9th, 2009 at 8:52 am

I’m wondering if McNair’s murder will stimulate conversation in an area rarely discussed, and that is the so-called “bad behavior” of athletes (and of course other men in positions of power, glamour and authority) where cheating is not only a risk and adrenaline rush but also a real sense of entitlement. I’ve dated a few professional athletes who spoke of how agents set up women for their married comrades, pay their bills for them, make sure Mistress 1 never crosses pathes with Mistress 2, and “manage” women in different geographical locations and very often the wives have no idea because these affairs are micromanaged. I’m not suggesting this is what happened with McNair, just providing a context. I think it’s interesting how hard they come down on athletes for gambling, steroid use, harming dogs, driving drunk, but they are rarely taken to task for adultery. Perhaps adultery is perceived as a “victimless” crime, although we know that is not the case. I am also wondering about this unfortunate young girl’s age will be discussed; she was barely legal (or is 18 the legal cut off age?) And FYI, a three time Bowl pick means he was selected to play in the Pro Bowl in Hawaii on three separate occasions. This game is usually played after the Super Bowl, and only the best of the best are asked to play. I love my football!

Kimberly
July 9th, 2009 at 10:17 am

I know that men (and women) of every stripe commit adultery. I also know that celebrities and politicians live in a bit of a fishbowl. However, the frequency with which infidelity seems to come up in the ranks of the very famous and/or elected officials makes me wonder whether one of 2 things is going on:

1 - Is there something about fame and/or power that makes one feel entitled to this kind of thing or above the ethical rules that apply to “mere mortals?” or

2 - Is there something about the personality type that seeks fame or power that makes one also likely to cheat?

geochick
July 9th, 2009 at 4:08 pm

Dr. Reems,
I agree with your post whole-heartedly. Men cheat for all the reasons you mention: patriarchal priviledge and so forth. But I’d like to add also because they experience few or no negative consequences from their behavior. The reaon for laws and punishment (negative consequences) is to manage human behavior otherwise everyone would do anything and everything they want to do without any restraints at all.

When it comes to male adultery everyone and everything else is blamed: the wife, the other woman, male’s high sex drive, evolution, polygamy not being condemned in the bible, males need variety in sexual partners, men are visual creatures, and on and on. Unlike cheating wives who have to fear: violence or death once husband finds out, spouse leaving or divorcing her, shame/disgrace/hatred and societal stigma from family and friends, MEN rarely experience any of these consequences. At most, his wife will cry and be angry which is understandable, may break things around the house, go on a spending spree, or may even withhold sex for a period of time but that’s pretty much the extent of it. And as mentioned earlier, society will celebrate his behavior. So why do men cheat? Because they gain more than they lose from doing so unless they’re extremely moral.

Kim
July 9th, 2009 at 6:02 pm

Dr. Weems, I hope you post this. I hope you will accept my apology for my big ole mouth, and not thinking about what I say. I’m notororious for that.

About McNair,

When I read this and let it roll around for a couple of days, this is what I determined.

So many men, especially brothers, cheat because they don’t know who they are. Many of them don’t know their purpose, don’t know how to love, and do not know their value. Although, this brother had an NFL career, a wife and four children, obviously something for him was still missing. I believe that he didn’t know who God called him to be or he was not walking fully in it. This is my opinion, I think he knew his purpose for work, being on the field. But I don’t think he realized the greater call was to his wife and the four lives he was responsible for. So many brothers lose in the world of work, they feel disrespected and have low self esteem, so the only way they think they can win is through their conquests. It is so sad.

Cammie
July 10th, 2009 at 7:04 am

Dr Weems,

When scripture is read, generally the reader will end with something along the lines of, “This is the word of God and it can be trusted”.

I must ask you, as a minister, to explain the following for me:

“But the Bible, at least the part written by men, doesn’t say that adultery is a sin. Not when it’s men doing it. Let me be more specific. Not when it’s a married man having an affair with an unmarried woman. It’s only an affair when he’s having an affair with another man’s wife. As for what the Bible has to say about when a married woman has an affair. Stone her . Whether her lover is married or not. Stone her to death.”

If the word of God can be trusted, why do we question the way things are supposed to “be” as described, explained and instructed in the BOOK? As a thinking woman, I question just about everything until I gain understanding.
How are we to discern which of “God’s Words” are fact versus those that are debatable. Perhaps men on some cellular level live and act as God intended. I in no way condone men cheating, it’s just that your statement was one of those things that made me go, hummm???

Robbi Oella
July 10th, 2009 at 11:16 am

Sisters,

You’re giving us too much cerebral credit. The reason why men cheat is pretty simple… It’s an option. In the same way that kids will eat as much candy is available to them, and other people will eat as many twinkies as they can stomach and another person will drive ass fast as they can. It’s simply because it’s desirable option. All of the things you all put forth are true of any sin. When we sin we don’t think about the real consequences, we just think about the gratification that we are being DENIED if we don’t choose to sin. We sin because we have the capacity to be extremely selfish and the opportunity to execute that selfishness.
So why do men cheat, for the same reasons we all go to McDonald’s, Burger King, White Castle’s, Pizza Hut, Wendy’s, and Taco Bell…it’s convenient, requires little investment, tastes good (salt, fat sugar),and you can just drive through and get what you want and be done. Men cheat for the same reasons we eat fast food.

Nick Peterson
July 10th, 2009 at 1:41 pm

@Nick,
But unlike an unfettered appetite for fast food/gluttony, cheating has a relational dimension. Gluttony is often a statement about how a person feels about herself. Infidelity speaks to your feelings about someone with whom you’re in relationship.
But I like you’re analogy about candy. It makes me ask why we allow men to develop an insatiable appetite for sex. Why is there gratification in unlimited sexual options, especially in the age of AIDS?

socgrad
July 10th, 2009 at 4:28 pm

@Socgrad - Gluttony and a disregard for ones health is just as destructive as infidelity. It can result in early death, the inability to actively participate in the life of one’s children. The selfishness of gluttony can be just as damaging to a family.

Sex is easy and it doesn’t take much to get a strong appetite for it. The problem is not just the appetite but how we don’t train our children male or female how to deal with the urges and desires for sex.

Nick Peterson
July 12th, 2009 at 11:29 am

@Nick,

You’re giving us too much cerebral credit. The reason why men cheat is pretty simple… It’s an option…Men cheat for the same reason we eat fat food.

Wow!!
I like to think that I am an old and wise enough to have lots of patience with and empathy for human weaknesses, even the ones I find objectionable. And I think I’ve looked wrong in the face enough and observed of human frailty long enough such that little surprises me. But your response floors me somewhat. I wanted to believe that even “cheating” is a little more complicated than what you’ve said, definitely more complicated than what many of my female commenters have proffered thus far. But perhaps you’re right. It’s an option that’s easy to seize and very gratifying. Plain and simple. Forget all those who it hurts.

If that’s true, we are all doomed.

On second thought, perhaps the question is not why do men cheat, but why do some men NOT cheat?

Renita
July 12th, 2009 at 2:43 pm

@ Dr. Weems - Some men don’t cheat because they fear being caught, had they little concern about this they would cheat, it’s a certain type of cowardice that keeps them at bay. These brothers look on at the cheating brothers with a certain type of envy. It’s like the cheating ride says you have to be 72″ and they’re on 70″, not quite up to the cheating standard, but would give anything to be there.

Still there are men who don’t cheat because they have the to sense to know that it ain’t worth it. For as much as the rush and the thrill will be exciting, fresh, and different, they’ve put too much into building what they already have. I think a lot of the non-cheaters fall into this category. These are the brothers who are actually trying to figure out how to grow and make their current relationship work. They are investing in the well-being of their home, wife, children, and community. They have a sense that their identity is not tied to who they can screw over, but to how the can train-up and partner well. This is a brother who’s taken to heart the practice of servant-lover. I know this sounds too idealistic, but to be a faithful man requires intention.

Now if we follow Jesus’ stinging definition of adultery, “If you so much as look…” Then yes, we are indeed all doomed. (bowing my head in sorrowful repentance…)

Nick Peterson
July 12th, 2009 at 6:55 pm

Men cheat for the simple reason that in a patriarchy, men program other men to believe that they can own their wives and many more. To do so is a sign not only of maleness but a sign of dominion. It’s in the air that they breathe from childhood. So for me, I am interested in those men who radically depart from this tradition and see women not as territories to be conquered but as an essential part of a landscape of worthwhile and equal humanity.. Subjects not objects.

Ruby Sales

Ruby Sales
July 13th, 2009 at 7:43 am

I agree wholeheartedly with Ruby Sales.

Amanda
July 13th, 2009 at 9:54 am

Chris Rock said it best…men are as faithful as their options. Plain and simple.

A Daughter of the King
July 20th, 2009 at 12:51 pm

You say…

What’s a wife to do? Get a life. Have a plan.

I wonder, have you ever been cheated on?

Do you know how it feels to come home from church and have your husband say to you “I don’t love you. I haven’t loved you for a long time.life’s too short to be miserable. I want out. I want to see other women.

Well, I do. It hurt. It still hurts even several years on. I’m sorry but saying “get a life” sounds far too flippant and insensitive to me. My “plan” was to stay married, but cheating hubby ruined that plan.

Why does it seem like you’re taking the man’s side here? or am I misinterpreting?

Sabs
July 21st, 2009 at 2:56 pm

It has been said that “steve McNair loved his wife and family” after this story of his murder broke on the news, but I wondered how could you love your wife and family and turn around and say to a women you just met and had a few “good” times that I love you too? It appears that he had some previous intimate relations before which produced some children, I wonder was this before or after his marriage? What kind of mixed-up mind did this young man possess? It takes a bit of thinking to get around on the football field, I wonder why he did not use this same intelligence in his personal life?

J. Marie
July 27th, 2009 at 9:51 am

One more thing about this topic, why do men cheat, maybe one should ask why do women put up with it? I quess we see that this young lady was not going to put up with it. I also noticed former President Bill Clinton remarks, “how his heart was broken over the incident” Heartbroken over the lost of life, or grateful over the fact that he did not go out that same way!

J. Marie
July 27th, 2009 at 11:39 am

Spot on, Dr. Weems. As someone who has been cheated on, “get a life and have a plan” is perfect advice. I am curious to know your take on the Tiger Woods cheating scandal. Also, I would love to know your views on the women of no morals who make themselves available to these married men.

M. Lacombe
December 4th, 2009 at 6:25 am


Leave Your Two Cents